Advertising for insurance agencies
Facebook Ads for Insurance Agents
Quote requests from people near you, set up the way Meta now wants insurance ads run.
- Since 2016
- 105+ WordPress sites supported
- MarTech Award 2023 & 2024
Are you paying for leads that other agents called first?
Your WP Guy runs Facebook ads for insurance agents, plus Instagram, Google and Bing ads. Your ads bring in your own quote requests, not names sold to many agents. We set them up in the insurance ad category Meta requires, and we count the quote requests your team works. Our ads management starts at $500 a week per platform, plus your ad spend.
Why insurance ad budgets leak
Your website should be your hardest-working employee, and ads should send it people ready for a quote. But most of what you read about insurance ads is out of date. It is hard to know what still works. That feels like gambling with your budget. Growing your agency should not take guesswork.
Advice Meta limited
Many guides still say to pick ages, ZIP codes and lookalikes. For insurance ads in the US, Meta limits or removes them.
Leads sold more than once
Bought leads often go to several agents at once. You race to call first, and the shopper gets a pile of calls.
Clicks instead of quotes
The report shows cheap clicks. Your team sees few quote requests worth a call back.
Three months at $3,000 is $9,000 of ad spend. Built on old targeting, much of it is wasted.
Facebook has its own rules for insurance ads
Since January 2025, Meta has put US insurance ads in a special category for money products. That changes who you can reach:
| What many guides still say | What Meta allows for insurance ads in the US |
|---|---|
| Pick ages 25 to 45 | Limited or unavailable. |
| Pick the ZIP codes you want | Limited or unavailable. A town or a pin gets a wider circle. |
| Copy your best clients with a lookalike | Limited or unavailable. |
| Leave out people who already bought | Limited. Some interests are gone too. |
So the ad has to find the right people on its own. We run one line per campaign, like home or business insurance. Each ad names a real moment, like a new home, a new driver or a renewal coming up.
Sources: Meta, About ads for financial products and services; Meta, Special Ad Categories, November 2026.
Google Ads for insurance agents
Google reaches people searching right now. But the biggest insurance searches are a bidding war with big carriers and quote sites. Searches for an agent cost far less:
| Search | Average searches a month | Cost per click |
|---|---|---|
| auto insurance quotes | 246,000 | $180.36 |
| home insurance quotes | 110,000 | $168.10 |
| car insurance near me | 74,000 | $68.89 |
| insurance agent near me | 40,500 | $23.83 |
| insurance agency near me | 27,100 | $19.52 |
| independent insurance agent near me | 9,900 | $21.08 |
Source: Google Ads data via DataForSEO, US, November 2026.
So we aim your Google budget at people looking for an agent near them. We skip the $180 quote clicks. In California and Florida, agencies can also run Local Services Ads with the Google Verified badge. See Local Services Ads management.
Source: Google Local Services Help, United States categories, November 2026.
Ads your carriers and compliance team see first
An ad speaks for your agency. Your carriers may limit what it says and whether it shows their logo. If you sell Medicare plans, your compliance team or upline signs off on those ads.
So every ad and landing page goes to you before it runs. You keep a dated copy of each one. We use carrier logos only with permission.
This is how we work, not legal or compliance advice.
What our insurance ads management includes
Setup, weekly checks and a monthly call.
Setup
- The Meta ad category set right
- One campaign per line you write
- Each ad sent to the right page
- Quote requests tracked on your site
Every week
- Each new ad sent to you first
- Quote requests checked with your team
- Google search terms read by a person
- Ads that bring no quotes paused
Every month
- New ads tested against the old ones
- Google, Bing and Facebook in one report
- Spend checked against your budget
- A report and a call with Jonathan
Insurance ads pricing
Management starts at $500 a week per platform, plus your ad spend. The first platform needs at least $3,000 a month in ad spend. We ask for 90 days, then it is month to month, and the accounts stay in your name.
Your WP Guy has run since 2016, and we won the MarTech Award in 2023 and 2024.
Want ads for people who came to your site? Retargeting starts at $250 a week, with at least $1,500 a month in ad spend. Need pages for the ads to land on? See insurance agency website design.
What you pay
$500/wkPer platform, plus your ad spend.
$3,000/moMinimum ad spend on the first platform.
90 daysThen month to month.
Already running ads?
Find out what your ads really sold
If your ads show lots of leads but few become policies, the tracking may count the wrong thing.
Our Facebook Ads audit and our Google Ads audit are $899 each, one time, or $1,500 for both. We add our own tracking for 15 days and compare what the ad account claims with your real quote requests. You get a written report and a call with Jonathan on day 21.
What we check
- The Meta category set right
- Each quote request counted once
- Money spent on $180 quote clicks
- Ads shown outside your area
- Landing pages that are slow on a phone
Your guide
An ads team that builds agency sites too
We get it. You have bought leads that were shared, or tried ads that brought thin ones.
Jonathan Wofford started Your WP Guy in 2016. He watches, checks and verifies every ad account with a senior team. We also build agency websites, so the page your ad opens has a quote form that works. You get peace of mind, because we have your back.
Insurance ads, in three steps
Talk to a WordPress expert
Pick a time for a short call. Tell us the lines you write, where you write them and what a new policy is worth.
We build the ads
Ads and offers for each line, sent to you before they run.
We check them every week
A monthly report on quote requests and a call with Jonathan. You get back to writing policies.
Facebook ads for insurance agents questions
Straight answers before you start.
Still not sure? Talk to a WordPress expert. A real person, not a bot.
Can insurance agents target by age on Facebook?
How much do Facebook ads for insurance agents cost?
Is running ads better than buying leads?
Do Facebook ads work for insurance agents?
Facebook ads or Google Ads?
Can insurance agencies use Local Services Ads?
Can you run Medicare ads?
Can our ads show carrier logos?
Can I run the ads myself?
Who owns the ad accounts?
Is there a long contract?
Get quotes that are yours alone
Picture a homeowner near you asking for a quote, and no other agent calling them first. Your website, your hardest-working employee, takes the request while your team writes policies. Talk to Jonathan, and you will know if ads fit your agency, whether you hire us or not.