Websites for insurance agencies

Insurance Agency Website Design

A website that brings in quotes and takes the calls your team should not have to.

  • Since 2016
  • 105+ WordPress sites supported
  • MarTech Award 2023 & 2024

How many calls a week are just "where do I pay my bill" or "can you send my ID card"?

Your WP Guy provides insurance website design for independent agencies, captive agents and brokers. Each line of insurance gets its own page. A short quote form sits on every page. Clients can pay, report a claim or get ID cards without calling. Insurance agency website design starts at $1,999.

Fernbrook Insurance Agency (insurance agency demo) website homepage
Fernbrook Insurance Agency (insurance agency demo)An insurance agency demo website we built, not a real agency

Demo site

Fernbrook, our insurance agency demo

We built Fernbrook Insurance Agency to show what an agency site can do. It is not a real agency, and a banner says so. The agents, license numbers, address and phone number are made up.

  1. The first screen says who you insure and offers a quote or a call.
  2. Six lines of insurance each get a card and a quote link.
  3. "How quoting works" explains your process in three steps.
  4. The quote form asks four questions and works with one thumb.
  5. "Already a client?" puts bill pay, claims and ID cards one tap away.
  6. Each agent shows a name and license number, and carrier logos have their own spot.

Shoppers and clients need different doors

Your team quotes, services and chases renewals all day. The website gets updated when someone has a spare hour, and that hour never comes. Meanwhile clients call for things a website could handle. It bugs you that the site is behind, and it is hard to know which web company to trust. It should not take a phone call to find an ID card.

Your website should be your hardest-working employee. Shoppers want a quote. Clients want help. Each should find their door in one tap:

Page Who it is for What it does
A page per line Shoppers Explains auto, home, business or life in plain words, with a quote button
Quote form Shoppers A few questions, sent straight to your team
Client service Your clients Pay a bill, report a claim, get ID cards, without a phone call
Claims help Clients after a loss What to do first, and each carrier's claim line
Agents Both Names, license numbers and a direct line for each agent
Carriers Shoppers The companies you represent, with each one's permission

When a shopper cannot find the quote form, they often fill one out on a site that sells their name to several agents. When a client cannot find the claim line, they call your office during your busiest hour.

Quote forms that reach your team

The quote form asks only what you need to call back: name, phone, ZIP code and the kind of insurance. Shorter forms get finished. You can ask the rest on the call.

Each request goes to your inbox, or to your agency system if it takes web leads. Every phone number is tap-to-call. We count forms and taps on your phone number, so you see what the site brings in.

Built around your carriers and your state

Insurance sites have rules other sites do not. Your carriers and your state decide what goes on your site. If you are a captive agent, your carrier may have its own rules for agent websites, so we go over them with you before we start.

If you sell Medicare Advantage plans for more than one company, CMS requires a set disclaimer, shown prominently on your website. It starts with "We do not offer every plan available in your area." We add it with the numbers your compliance team gives us.

We show each agent's license number, and we use carrier logos only with each carrier's permission.

Source: 42 CFR 422.2267(e)(41), CMS third-party marketing disclaimer, November 2026. This is how we build, not legal advice.

Agent pages that match Google

Google treats insurance agents as individual practitioners. A public-facing agent can have their own Google Business Profile, separate from the agency's.

So each agent gets a page with the same name, phone and office as their Google profile. On every page we add InsuranceAgency schema, so search engines read your agency correctly. See our insurance agent SEO.

Untitled design - 2025-10-21T143217.379

Your guide

One team, from launch to renewal season

We get it. Your agency lives on trust, and an old website quietly works against it.

Jonathan Wofford started Your WP Guy in 2016. Our team builds and looks after 105+ WordPress websites for small businesses. When you add a carrier, hire an agent or change your hours, the people who built your site can make the change. You get peace of mind, because we have your back.

We have won the Innovation in Business MarTech Award for Best Website Maintenance Company twice, in 2023 and 2024.

What an agency site includes

Built for phones first.

Shoppers

  • A page for each line you write
  • A short quote form on every page
  • Tap-to-call phone numbers
  • Carrier logos, with permission

Clients

  • Bill pay and claim links by carrier
  • ID card and certificate requests
  • Claims help: what to do first
  • Policy change requests

Trust

  • A page per agent, with license numbers
  • Medicare disclaimer if you sell it
  • InsuranceAgency schema
  • Quote requests and call taps counted

What an insurance agency website costs

Custom WordPress sites start at $1,999. Most of our clients spend $6,000 to $10,000, paid in 2 to 4 payments. The site and domain are in your name.

You can see the pages first in our Fernbrook demo.

Plan on about 45 days when your content arrives on time, or 75 to 90 days when it trickles in.

Not included

Insurance website pricing

$1,999Where custom sites start.

45 daysWhen content arrives on time.

FixedOne quote, agreed before work starts.

From kickoff to launch

Talk to a WordPress expert

Pick a time. Tell us the lines you write, your carriers and how quotes come in today.

We build it right

Line pages, the quote form and the client service links first. We send a test quote request from a phone before launch.

Your website gets to work

Your site goes live, and your team gets back to quoting and serving clients.

Insurance agency website questions

From agency owners and principals.

Still not sure? Talk to a WordPress expert. A real person, not a bot.

How much does an insurance agency website cost?

Can we see an example of an insurance agency site?

Is Fernbrook a real insurance agency?

Can a captive agent have their own website?

Can the quote form go into our agency management system?

Can you put carrier logos on our site?

Do you add the Medicare disclaimer?

Can we pay in parts?

How long does it take?

Is the website ADA compliant?

Can our staff update the site?

Do we own the website?

Let the website answer the phone

A shopper finds your home insurance page and asks for a quote at 9 at night. A client grabs an ID card from the parking lot. Your team spends the day quoting instead of looking things up. Your website does that work, like your hardest-working employee.