SEO for insurance agencies

Insurance Agent SEO

Be the agent they call when they search, not the one they scroll past.

  • Since 2016
  • 105+ WordPress sites supported
  • MarTech Award 2023 & 2024

Do people in your town find a big-name call center before they find you?

Your WP Guy provides SEO for insurance agents, brokers and agencies, independent or captive. We help you show up in the map, in the regular results and on Bing when people search for the coverage you write. We set up your listings, build a page for each line of insurance and fix your website ourselves. Insurance agent SEO starts at $875 a week, month to month.

Why good agents get skipped online

Your website should be your hardest-working employee. It should bring in quote requests while you are with clients. Here is what gets in the way.

A profile set up the wrong way

Google has its own rules for insurance agents. A profile with extra words in the name, the wrong category or profiles for office staff can keep you out of the map.

One page for every line

Auto, home, life and business insurance crammed onto one page. Google cannot tell which one you want to be found for.

The same words as other agents

If your site came with ready-made pages about coverage, the same words are often on many other agents' sites. Nothing on them says why you.

Every quote request that goes to the agent above you is a client you never got to talk to.

Untitled design - 2025-10-21T143217.379

Your guide

An insurance SEO company that can fix the website too

We get it. You want clients who call you, not another marketing login.

Jonathan Wofford started Your WP Guy in 2016. Our team looks after WordPress websites for small businesses every day. When we find a problem, our developers fix it in your site. You get peace of mind, because we have your back.

We have won the Innovation in Business MarTech Award for Best Website Maintenance Company twice, in 2023 and 2024.

What our insurance agent SEO includes

Local SEO for insurance agents, plus the website work that most SEO companies hand back to you.

Your map listings

  • Google Business Profile set up the way Google's rules ask for agents
  • The right main category, and as few extras as you need
  • Office hours, photos and the lines you write
  • Bing Places and Apple Business, so you show up beyond Google
  • A simple way to ask every client for a review

Your website

  • A page for each line of insurance you want more of
  • Agent bios with photos and experience
  • License details where clients look for them
  • A quote form that works on a phone
  • Insurance agency schema, so Google knows what you are

Growth and tracking

  • The searches your clients use, by line and town
  • Links from local partners, chambers and community groups
  • Calls and quote requests tracked, not just rankings
  • AEO and GEO: ChatGPT and Google AI checked monthly
  • A plain-English report every month

Your Google profile, the way Google asks

Google counts insurance agents as individual practitioners, like doctors and lawyers. That changes how your profile should be set up.

Your office How Google wants your profile
You are the only agent at a branded office Share one profile with the brand, named like Google's own example: "Allstate: Joe Miller".
Several agents work at one office The office gets its own profile. Each agent who meets clients there can also have one, named with only the name of the agent.
An independent agency Use your real agency name, with no extra words like "Best Auto Insurance".
Office and support staff No profile. Google says support staff should not have their own, and no agent should have one for each line they sell.

Your carrier agreement and your state decide what can go on your site and in your ads. We follow your rules and theirs.

Red flags in an insurance SEO proposal

Agents get pitched SEO tricks all the time. Some can get a profile pulled. Here they are, checked against Google's rules.

Red flag Why it matters
"We guarantee you will rank #1" Google's own advice on hiring an SEO says no one can guarantee a #1 ranking.
Adding keywords or towns to your profile name Google's Business Profile rules do not allow extra words in your name. It puts your listing at risk.
A page for every town with only the name swapped Google's spam rules name pages made for different cities that all lead to one place. They can hurt the whole site.
Rewards for reviews Google's review policy bans any reward for reviews, even a small gift card.
Only asking happy clients Google does not allow asking only the clients you expect to be happy. Ask everyone.
The SEO company owns your website If you leave, you lose it. Your site, your domain and your Google profile should be in your name.

Insurance SEO or paid ads?

Google Ads for finance and insurance average $3.39 a click and $74.44 for each lead, according to LocaliQ's 2026 national averages. That category mixes banks, lenders and insurance. Every new lead costs that again, and so do bought leads.

With SEO, the price stays the same when more people find you. It is slow to start and keeps paying off. Plenty of agencies run both: ads for this quarter's quotes, SEO for the next few years. See our Google Ads management, from $500 a week plus ad spend.

Insurance agent SEO pricing

$875/wkMonth to month, for agents and agencies.

3 monthsBefore you judge the results.

1 reportEach month: calls, quote requests and next steps.

Ad costs: LocaliQ search advertising benchmarks, 2026, Finance and Insurance.

Not ready for monthly SEO? SEO Research is a one-time audit with a to-do list, from $2,999. If you start monthly SEO within 60 days, half of it counts toward it.

How agency SEO starts

A look at your market

Your profile, your site and the agents above you.

Profile and pages

Categories, bios and a page for each line you write, set up by our team.

Quote requests over time

Line pages, reviews and local links each month, with a report on quote requests.

Insurance agent SEO questions

What agents and agency owners ask.

Still not sure? Talk to a WordPress expert. A real person, not a bot.

How much does SEO for insurance agents cost?

How long does insurance SEO take?

Can I do SEO for my insurance agency myself?

I am a captive agent. Can I have my own website?

What should my Google profile be called?

Do I need a page for every town I serve?

Do you do SEO for Bing too?

Do you do AEO and GEO?

Do I own my website and listings?

Let your hardest-working employee bring in the quotes

Show up when people near you search for the coverage you write. Talk to Jonathan about your agency.