The short version
The site publishes good, timely WordPress news, but Google barely sees it. For every article, the site hands Google about 39 near-empty category pages, so Google spends its time on those instead of the articles. Every search in this market shows a Google AI Overview, and the AI tools quote wordpress.org, Reddit, Wordfence and WPBeginner, never this site. The fix is in three parts: clear out the category pages and connect the articles (weeks 1 to 3), build the 5 guides and comparisons people actually search for (weeks 3 to 9), then build trust and get quoted by AI (weeks 9 to 12).
What we found
1. 7,554 empty category pages are burying 192 articles Impact: high Effort: medium
What we saw
The sitemaps list 7,554 category pages, 192 articles (17 of them listed twice) and 4 other pages. Most categories were created one per plugin, company or topic (for example /category/10up/, /category/2020-euros/, /category/404-plugin/). Our crawler checks a site the way Google does: it hit its 1,500-page limit while still inside the category pages, after reaching only 28 of the 192 articles. 1,460 of the pages it read have fewer than 150 words, 1,468 have no links pointing to them, and 1,472 have no main heading.
What Search Console shows
Google last read the sitemap on April 7, 2025, 18 months ago, so it has not been told about anything published since. We asked Google about the 4 main pages and the first 60 articles in the sitemap: it has 9 of the 64 in its index, 2 more it crawled but left out, and 53 it has never heard of, including the Contact page. Over the last 16 months the site showed up in Google 25,260 times and got 19 clicks. The biggest drop came with the May 2026 core update, when Google showed the site less than half as often. Core updates judge the quality of the whole site, which is what thousands of thin category pages pull down.
| Google update | Date | Showing up per day, 2 weeks before | Showing up per day, weeks 2 to 3 after |
|---|---|---|---|
| May 2026 core update | May 21 | 107 | 46 |
| June 2026 spam update | June 24 | 54 | 35 |
| August 2026 spam update | August 18 | 30 | 106 |
| September 2026 spam update | September 24 | 28 | 32 |
Why it matters
Google gives every site a limited amount of attention. Thousands of thin pages use it up, and they drag down how Google judges the whole site, articles included.
What to do
Cut to about 10 real topic categories, keep the rest out of Google, and remove them from the sitemap. Work order 1
2. Every search shows a Google AI Overview Impact: high Effort: medium
What we saw
We checked all 32 searches the site should win, plus the new ones below. Google shows an AI-written answer above the results for every single one. None of them shows a map pack or shopping results, so the AI Overview and the regular results are the only places to be seen.
Why it matters
When an AI Overview shows, many readers get their answer without clicking. The sites that still win are the ones Google quotes inside the AI Overview. Ranking alone is not enough here: each page needs a short, direct answer near the top, clear lists and tables, a named expert author, and a visible date.
What to do
Every page plan and work order in this report is written for AI Overview searches. Work order 5 covers the article format.
3. The searches people make most have no matching page Impact: high Effort: high
What we saw
We researched 2,200 related searches and picked the 32 that fit what the site covers. The biggest are guides and comparisons, like "wordpress security plugin" and "wordpress vs wix". The site writes news about these topics but has no guide or comparison page for most of them.
| What people search | Searches a month | What Google shows | Which page should win it | Today |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| wordpress security plugin | 2,400 | AI Overview | New guide: Best WordPress Security Plugins (page plan 1) | #80, with a news article |
| wordpress vs wix, wix vs wordpress | 1,900 | AI Overview | New comparison: WordPress vs Wix (page plan 3) | No page |
| wordpress vs squarespace | 1,900 | AI Overview | Add to the WordPress vs Wix comparison | No page |
| wordpress backup plugin, updraftplus | 1,000 + 880 | AI Overview | New guide: Best Backup Plugins (page plan 4) | No page |
| wordpress 7 | 1,000 | AI Overview | Existing WordPress 7 news articles (link them together) | Not in the top 100 |
| wordpress vs webflow | 880 | AI Overview | Existing comparison (page plan 2) | Not in the top 100 |
| best ecommerce platform, woocommerce vs shopify | 880 + 880 | AI Overview | Existing comparison (page plan 5) | Not in the top 100 |
| wordpress com vs wordpress org | 880 | AI Overview | New explainer | No page |
| wordpress hacked, wordpress malware removal | 390 + 320 | AI Overview | Existing breach stories, plus a how-to guide | Not in the top 100 |
| wordpress vulnerability, wordpress security news | 320 | AI Overview | A Security News hub page (work order 1) | Not in the top 100 |
What to do
Build the guides and comparisons in order of demand. Growth includes 5 detailed plans: 2 new pages and 3 existing articles to improve.
Keywords to go after
We pulled every search 5 similar WordPress sites rank for in Google's top 20 (BlogVault, WP Umbrella, WPMarmite, WatchmanTower and CMSMinds): 1,333 searches. After removing their own names, other languages and anything already on the list, 840 were left. These are the best of them. Search counts are US totals.
| New search to go after | Searches a month (US) | What Google shows | Who ranks today | Page that should win it |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| wordpress seo plugins | 6,600 | AI Overview | WPMarmite #16, BlogVault #19 | New guide: Best SEO Plugins |
| wp rocket | 3,600 | AI Overview | WPMarmite #10, BlogVault #15 | New review: WP Rocket |
| wordpress page builder | 2,900 | AI Overview | WPMarmite #9 | New comparison: Page Builders |
| revisions wordpress | 1,900 | AI Overview | BlogVault #8 | New how-to: Using Revisions |
| latest wordpress version | 1,600 | AI Overview | CMSMinds #6 | A WordPress Versions page, updated each release |
| wordpress redirect plugin | 1,600 | AI Overview | WPMarmite #16, BlogVault #10 | New guide: Redirect Plugins |
| wordpress performance plugin | 1,000 | AI Overview | BlogVault #7 | New guide: Speed Plugins |
| wp backup plugin | 1,000 | AI Overview | BlogVault #4 | Backup guide (page plan 4) |
| wordpress website cost | 1,000 | AI Overview | CMSMinds #15 | New explainer: What a WordPress Site Costs |
What else we found
4. Articles are not connected to each other Impact: high Effort: medium
What we saw
Pages scored 3.7 of 10 for how well they link to each other. Many articles have no links from other articles. Once a story scrolls off the latest-posts list, little points to it.
What to do
Link each news story to the matching guide, and link related stories together. Work order 2
5. No named expert behind the articles Impact: high Effort: low
What we saw
Every article is credited to the site's own name, not a person, and the site has no About page. Even the article schema lists the author as a "person" whose name is the site's name. Trust signals scored 0 of 10: no named author, no credentials, no editorial policy. Schema and dates are in decent shape (5.6 of 10).
Why it matters
For security and how-to advice, Google and AI tools favor content from a named, experienced person. It is one of the clearest differences between the pages AI quotes and this site.
What to do
Add a real author with a bio and credentials, an About page, and a short editorial policy. Work order 4
6. AI tools quote other sites Impact: medium Effort: medium
What we saw
We asked ChatGPT, Gemini, Perplexity and Google AI Mode 8 questions readers ask, like "What is the best security plugin for WordPress in 2026?" and "Should I use WordPress or Wix for a small business website?". None of the 32 answers named the site. These are the sites they cited most (times cited, out of 32 answers):
What to do
Write for the way AI quotes, and be present where AI looks (Reddit and the WordPress.org forums). The 5 AI breakdowns show exactly what the cited pages do. Work order 5
7. Fewer trusted links than similar sites Impact: medium Effort: high
What we saw
Authority is how much search engines trust a site, on a scale of 0 to 1,000. Similar WordPress sites sit between 255 and 542; this site is at 175. (Raw link counts look similar across all of them, because the same spam networks link to every WordPress site, so authority is the number to watch.)
What to do
Earn links with things other sites want to cite: a running WordPress vulnerability tracker, original data, and expert quotes for journalists. Work order 6
8. A slow homepage, partly from the categories Impact: medium Effort: low
What we saw
We ran Google's own speed test (Lighthouse, phone). Google only publishes speed data from real visitors once a site has enough traffic, and this site does not have enough yet, so these are lab results. Google's target is to show the main content within 2.5 seconds. The homepage takes 13.5 seconds. One reason: a category drop-down in the sidebar lists all 7,554 categories, adding about 600 KB of code. The site does not get enough visitors for Google's real-visitor speed data, so these are lab tests.
| Page | Speed score | Main content shows in | Page size |
|---|---|---|---|
| Homepage | 67 of 100 | 13.5 seconds | 4.5 MB |
| WordPress vs Webflow article | 76 of 100 | 5.3 seconds | 0.6 MB |
What to do
Remove the category drop-down and compress the homepage images. Work order 7
What it could be worth
Traffic if the 5 planned pages reach Google's top 3, or page 1. Every one of these searches shows an AI Overview, so we use a typical click rate (about 18% for the top 3, about 4% for positions 4 to 10) cut by 40% for the AI Overview.
| Page plan | Searches a month (US) | Visits a month if top 3 | Visits a month if on page 1 (4 to 10) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best WordPress Security Plugins | 2,790 | about 300 | about 65 |
| WordPress vs Wix (and Squarespace) | 4,390 | about 475 | about 105 |
| Best Backup Plugins | 2,200 | about 240 | about 55 |
| WordPress vs Webflow | 880 | about 95 | about 20 |
| Best Ecommerce Platforms | 2,240 | about 240 | about 55 |
| Total | 12,500 | about 1,350 | about 300 |
Revenue: once Analytics is connected, we multiply these visits by what a visit is worth on this site today (affiliate clicks, sign-ups and leads per visit). An estimate, not a promise.
Your 90-day plan
Weeks 1 to 3: clear the clutter
Weeks 3 to 9: build what people search
- Best WordPress Security Plugins and WordPress vs Wix (new)
- Upgrade the Webflow and ecommerce comparisons
- Best Backup Plugins (new)
- Then: SEO plugins, page builders, WP Rocket